Comparatifs
Nextcloud vs ownCloud
Comparez les deux forks cloud privé : fonctionnalités, apps, licences et lequel convient à votre homelab.
Nextcloud s'est séparé d'ownCloud il y a des années et est devenu l'option la plus communautaire. Les deux offrent sync, partage et apps, mais les licences et écosystèmes diffèrent.
Notre choix
Nextcloud pour la plupart des homelabbers
Différences clés
| Fonctionnalité | Nextcloud | ownCloud |
|---|---|---|
| License | AGPL | Mixed / enterprise tiers |
| App ecosystem | Very large | Smaller |
| Mobile apps | Excellent | Good |
| Community | Huge | Smaller |
| Community and apps | Very large | Smaller |
| Photos | Memories/Photos apps | Basic |
Verdict
Choisissez Nextcloud pour son app store, son développement actif et sa licence AGPL. ownCloud Infinite Scale seulement si vous avez des besoins entreprise spécifiques.
Where the two projects stand
Nextcloud and ownCloud share a common origin: Nextcloud was forked from ownCloud in 2016. Nextcloud has since grown a larger community and a broader app ecosystem (Talk, Office integrations, Calendar, Contacts, Notes and more). ownCloud has refocused on performance and enterprise file sync with its newer Infinite Scale product. For a home server, the two are no longer interchangeable.
Features
Nextcloud is a full collaboration platform: files, calendar, contacts, chat and video calls, notes, tasks and many apps, with a large app store. ownCloud focuses on file sync and sharing and does it with a lighter footprint in its newer versions. If you want to replace Google Drive and more, Nextcloud is the natural choice. See our [Nextcloud installation guide](/blog/setup-nextcloud).
Performance and maintenance
Nextcloud can feel slow if it is not tuned: use a proper database, Redis for caching, PHP OPcache, and fast storage. ownCloud Infinite Scale is designed for speed, but has a different architecture and fewer apps. Either way, run it behind HTTPS and keep it updated, because file servers are a prime target; see the [security checklist](/blog/home-server-security-checklist).
Which should you choose?
For most home users: Nextcloud, because of the community, app ecosystem and guides. Consider ownCloud if you only need fast file sync and prefer its architecture. For photos, many people pair either with [Immich](/blog/setup-immich-photos).